Cover photo for Carl Eugene Herr's Obituary
Carl Eugene Herr Profile Photo
0036 Carl 2023

Carl Eugene Herr

April 3, 0036 — November 5, 2023


Carl Eugene Herr, age 87, went to be with Jesus on the morning of November 5, 2023. He was a resident of Westminster Village North in Indianapolis, and formerly of Hershey and New Oxford, Pennsylvania.



Carl was born on April 3, 1936, the first of four children. He was the son of Lloyd and Martha (Cave) Herr, and brother of Robert, Arlene, and Kenneth.



Carl met his future wife, Alma, at the age of 16 and they were married for 67 years. Carl graduated from Pennsylvania State University in 1957, a year after he and Alma married. He would later receive a master’s degree from Penn State in 1968. They settled near Hershey, where they raised their two children, Vern and Eileen.



Carl’s life was dedicated to education and service. He was a teacher, administrator, and leader in his church and community. Carl’s first career was in the field of vocational agriculture, serving as an educator, a school principal, and an education consultant. He was also Executive Director of the Pennsylvania State Council of Vocational Education. He had a second career as the Executive Director of The Brethren Home, a senior retirement community in New Oxford, Pennsylvania.



Carl was a man of deep faith. He was a member of the Hanoverdale Church of the Brethren in Hershey, Pennsylvania where he taught Sunday School and served as a youth advisor, deacon, commission chairperson, and church moderator. After moving to New Oxford, he served as a teacher and board member at Bermudian Church of the Brethren.



Carl and Alma moved to Indiana in 1996 to be closer to family. Carl was a loving and devoted grandfather. “Poppa” enjoyed taking his grandchildren on educational trips and working together in his workshop.



Carl’s life of service continued in Indianapolis. He was a prominent figure at Geist Christian Church as a teacher, deacon, elder, men’s prayer group leader, and member of the Stephen Ministry team. He and Alma also led Prison Fellowship Ministry for over 14 years at the Correctional Facility in Pendleton, Indiana.

In 2016, Carl and Alma moved to Westminster Village North. There, Carl was active in the Resident’s Council and served as President. The family wishes to thank the Westminster Village staff for their kind and caring support over the years.



Carl is survived by his wife, Alma Ruth (Shenk), their children: Vern Herr (Victoria Martin Herr) of Norcross, Georgia and Eileen Herr (David Klinestiver) of Indianapolis, and their grandchildren: Natalie Herr of Marietta, GA, Brendan Herr of Nashville, TN, Daniel Klinestiver of Indianapolis, and Julia Klinestiver of New York, NY.



Family and friends will gather for a visitation from 12-2 PM at Geist Christian Church on Saturday, November 11th with a memorial service to immediately follow at 2 PM. The service will be available virtually:



In lieu of flowers, contributions may be made to Geist Christian Church or to Heifer Project International in memory of Carl:

To order memorial trees or send flowers to the family in memory of Carl Eugene Herr, please visit our flower store.


Visits: 299

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the
Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Service map data © OpenStreetMap contributors

Send Flowers

Send Flowers

Plant A Tree

Plant A Tree